If you’re searching for the best ideas for your baby's first Easter basket, you’re in the right spot. From snuggly keepsakes to fun little finds that actually get used, these sweet picks will make your baby’s basket just as special as the big kids’.
Putting together your baby's first Easter basket is such a sweet way to celebrate, but it’s easy to wonder what’s actually worth buying (and what’s better to skip) when they barely know what’s going on.
As a mom of two who’s been through the baby stage and beyond, I’ve figured out exactly what to put in Easter baskets to make them simple, meaningful, and full of things you’ll actually use.
You’ll learn exactly what kinds of items create that perfect mix of fun and practical and how to pull it all together in a way that feels just right.
This post is all about what to put in your baby's first Easter basket to save you the trouble of figuring it out yourself!
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I’ll receive a commission if you purchase through my link, at no extra cost to you.
What to Put in an Easter Basket
Here’s how to put together a really great Easter basket without spending money on fluff and unnecessary junk: focus mostly on things your baby already needs, then add a few fun items to round it out.
Think about what your baby will need next. Summer is coming, and you might not have those items yet. Maybe you’re getting ready to start solids or realizing you don’t have stacking toys to practice new skills. You were going to buy these things anyway, so you might as well make them part of the basket.
You can even shop your own house. We all grab things ahead of time and stash them in the closet for later, right? Perfect Easter basket material. I did this with my daughter by adding two sleepers in the next size up that were already washed and ready, plus a teether toothbrush I hadn’t given her yet. This trick works just as well for Christmas stockings, too.
Then, if you want, add a couple fun toys or something festive. This holiday is sweet, and it’s okay to lean into that a little.
Below are practical and fun ideas for a baby’s Easter basket that just make sense.
Practical Baby Essentials
If you’re trying to build an Easter basket that actually gets used, start here. Things like pacifiers, baby lotion, or even a sippy cup (if your baby is over 6 months) are everyday staples that won’t end up shoved in a drawer. These items may not be the cutest, but they’re the ones parents quietly appreciate the most, especially when money is tight and baby supplies add up fast.
Feeding Accessories
Feeding gear makes great basket fillers because it’s small, affordable, and easy to justify. Silicone spoons or snack cups (for older babies) are practical without feeling boring, and they’re items parents often forget to buy until they suddenly need them. If your baby is starting solids soon, this is one of those “you’ll be glad you grabbed it” categories.
Teething & Sensory Toys
Teething toys and sensory items are a safe bet for almost any baby age. Silicone teethers, crinkle toys, textured sensory balls, and rattle toys are simple, development-friendly, and don’t take up much space. These are the kinds of toys babies actually reach for, chew on, and toss around daily, which is really all you can ask for.
Books for Babies
You can never go wrong with a board book. Easter-themed board books are fun for the holiday itself, but regular board books or high-contrast books are just as valuable and last much longer. Books are budget-friendly, easy to store, and one of those gifts that never feels like clutter, even if baby already has a shelf full.
Soft Toys & Comfort Items
A small stuffed animal or lovey adds a cozy, comforting element to a baby’s first Easter basket. This isn’t the category to go overboard in. One soft toy is plenty and often becomes the one they sleep with, chew on, or drag around the house. Simple is better here.
Developmental Toys for Baby
This is where play meets learning without feeling overly “educational.” Stacking cups, pull rings or grasp toys, Montessori-style wooden toys, and baby-safe pop-it style toys all support fine motor skills and curiosity. These toys grow with your baby and get used far beyond Easter morning.
Clothing, Wearables & Accessories
Clothes are always a safe addition, especially if you size up. Onesies, socks, bibs, or a simple bow or headband can round out the basket without costing much. Try to keep this practical. Cute is great, but comfortable and wearable wins every time.
Bath & Care Items
Bath items are surprisingly useful Easter basket additions. Baby washcloths, a hooded towel, or a simple bath toy feel special without being wasteful. These items get regular use and don’t feel like a splurge, which is exactly what many new parents need.
Keepsake & Memory Items
Keepsakes are meaningful, but this is where less is more. A “My First Easter” onesie, an Easter picture frame, or a baby handprint or footprint kit is enough to mark the milestone without turning the basket into something overwhelming. Pick one item that feels special and call it good.
Summer-ready Items for Baby
Since Easter often kicks off warmer weather, summer essentials are a smart and practical choice. A sun hat, baby sunglasses, a rash guard or swimsuit, or even a stroller fan can be incredibly useful in the weeks ahead. These items feel thoughtful and forward-thinking, not seasonal throwaways.
Putting together your baby’s first Easter basket can be such a sweet, fun little moment. It’s a chance to enjoy picking things out and celebrating the season, without feeling like you need to go overboard. A few practical essentials, one or two fun or sentimental touches, and you’re done. Your baby won’t remember the basket itself, but you’ll remember the season, the photos, and how small they were. Keep it simple, spend wisely, and enjoy the moment- that’s more than enough.